News & Reviews

Bach meets Moondog

Symphony Hall, Birmingham

19 April 2006

Joanna MacGregor

Britten Sinfonia

 

To get into the authentic spirit of this music we should have been standing outside in the rain with the beggars, not sitting in a dispiritingly half-full Symphony Hall. For the Britten Sinfonia and that indefatigable explorer of sonic byways, Joanna MacGregor, were revisiting the extraordinary compositions of Moondog, the blind street musician who for decades plied his trade in a home-made Viking outfit opposite Carnegie Hall in New York, and counted among his admirers everyone from Igor Stravinsky and Charlie Parker to Bob Dylan and William Burroughs.

Kansas-born Moondog (real name Louis Thomas Hardin) died seven years ago at 83. But the cult popularity of his proto-minimalist pieces — a jaw-dropping 80 symphonies (admittedly very short ones) and 300 rounds — grows by the year. I’m not surprised. He wove fantastical counterpoints, sometimes in a dozen or more parts, over riffs that evoke Moroccan bazaars or Native American tom-toms as much as Manhattan jazz clubs.

MacGregor has taken 14 of Moondog’s pieces and evocatively reconceived them for a small orchestra, including herself on piano, saxophonist Andy Sheppard, and a rhythm section featuring the hypnotic patter of the tabla virtuoso Kuljit Bhamra . Really this music should hit you from four yards away, not via amplification into rather washy acoustics. You could tell that myriad interesting things were going on, but not always hear the detail.

That said, the music’s energy, tunefulness and sheer oddity were mesmerising. Whistles, sirens and other street sounds all figure. So does singing and shouting. But Moondog’s real genius was for piling up instrumental lines like a juggler insouciantly spinning more and more plates. You wait for the crash, but somehow the whirligig careers merrily on.

In an inspired bit of programming, an even greater contrapuntalist was summoned to follow him. MacGregor’s orchestration of Bach’s valedictory tour de force, The Art of Fugue , is no purist exercise. It’s full of surreally disembodied chords, wild brass interventions, sudden veiled reminiscences of a more elegant age, and then frantic jazz interludes that whizz off at a tangent (none more hair-raising than the stomp that takes over where Bach’s manuscript breaks off).

But I was riveted. It’s good news that MacGregor and co are recording it this week.

 

Richard Morrison, The Times

© Britten Sinfonia